What YES captures
accepted with caveat
Claim surface
Scoped readings
The answer split into scoped claims.
What NO uncovers
caveat active
Original claim — too broad
Claim state: PARKED
Not deleted. Not accepted. Conditions preserved.
Parked means reopenable under stated evidence, refutation, or context conditions.
PARKED
Claim graph
Y/N → parked → challenges
supports
parked
contested / reopenable
Next actions
What would move this claim state?
The dispute is now a set of small, assignable evidence tasks.